** Ethylene glycol vs. Propylene
glycol
Borates are sometimes formulated in a
liquid called glycol.
Glycol is described as a "penetrant" in that the
liquid is supposed to carry the borate deeper into
wood fibers. Manufacturers of glycol-based borate
products, such as Shell-Guard and Bora Care, use two
different chemical forms of glycol called ethylene
and propylene glycol. While both forms
are effective at carrying borate into wood fibers
the compounds are radically different in terms of
their toxicity to animals and humans.
Ethylene glycol is an odorless,
colorless, syrupy liquid that is widely used as an
engine coolant, or antifreeze. Ethylene glycol has a
sweet taste but is highly
toxic and accidental ingestion is a medical
emergency. Bora-Care uses ethylene glycol as its
glycol base.
Propylene glycol also is an
odorless, colorless liquid but it is tasteless
and much less toxic
than ethylene glycol. Because it lacks the sweet
taste of ethylene glycol, propylene glycol is also
less likely to be accidentally ingested by children
or pets. There is at least one brand of antifreeze
(Sierra Brands) that uses this less toxic form of
glycol and Shell-Guard is also based on this less
toxic form of glycol.
|